The present church was built in 1844-1845 and is a Grade II listed building. At the time of building Broad Town was not a civil parish, but was split between Broad Hinton and Clyffe Pypard. It was proposed in 1843 that because of the distance people in Broad Town had to travel to get to church in Broad Hinton or Clyffe Pypard, a church should be built in the village of Broad Town.
The land was given by Horatio Nelson Goddard; he belonged to the Goddard family who were local landowners. Subscriptions for the structure totalled £664.6s.5d., which meant the building could begin. Eight members of the Goddard family gave money and a large amount of money was also given by the Marchioness of Ailesbury. The church is found at the north end of the main street running through Broad Town and was built to the designs of W. Hinton Campbell. The church was consecrated on 12th April 1845 by Doctor Davison, the Lord Bishop of Salisbury. It was at that point known as the Consolidated Chapelry of Broad Town in the parish of Broad Hinton.