A church is first recorded in 1276 and the advowson belonged to the lord of the manor until the 16th century. In 1291 the Rectory was taxed at £5, and in 1341 the benefice was valued at £5.18s.0d. At this time the water mill was paying tithes of 3 shillings. During the period 1369-70 it was said 16 tenants owed services to the lord of the manor - bean picking, sheep shearing, sheep washing, hoeing, weeding, hay making and stacking, also harvest duties. In addition they were said to be liable for ploughing and hay carting duties. Queen Katherine Parr held the manor and on her death in 1548 the advowson reverted to the Crown.
Parishioners complained in 1553 that ‘there was no preaching in Tockenham’. In 1650 the rector claimed the parishioners paid no tithes, neither in kind nor payment. William Durston, rector in 1686 was described as ‘a scandalous and disorderly man’ and in 1692 it was reported he only visited the village once in six months. During this period the rector was also accused of taking away the communion vessels. Eventually a chalice and paten hallmarked 1681 were returned and these constitute the church plate in the 20th century.