The church of St. James is built on the highest point of the small parish of Stert. Although what currently stands, there has been a place of worship at the same location for at least 750 years.
Originally, a chapel, mentioned in c.1232, was on the site of the church, granted by Reverend John de Brokensford, the rector of Urchfont, to support a vicar serving Urchfont church. Evidence shows that ever since, the church has remained a chapelry of Urchfont ever since and the rector was required to appoint a chaplain to serve Stert. Until the 16th century, it is known that due to the reformation, King Henry VIII ensured that any donations given to the church at that time went towards the conflict against Turkey. This affected this church in particular along with many others in the country.